Eating for you


Eating for you

Dietary Supplement Savvy By Carol Plotkin, MS, RD



Below is an article that first appeared in the March 2006 edition of  Rochester Healthy Living.  As part of the article, local nutritionists were asked about the supplements they use.  Among the nutritionists interviewed ... Eating for You (and baby too)'s dietitian, Maggie McHugh, MS, RD, CDN.

 

Dietary Supplement Savvy By Carol Plotkin, MS, RD

Ever wonder if you should take a supplement to prevent arthritis pain? How about a supplement to stop a cold? One in three Americans takes a dietary supplement hoping to prevent illness. We believe that the vitamins, minerals, and other molecules in foods can keep us well. But when we take the nutrients out of food and put it in a pill, we don’t always see the health benefits we expect to see. These molecules act in our bodies along with other nutrients in ways we don’t quite comprehend. This action cannot always be mimicked by nutrients in a pill. Supplements can add some value to one’s health, and by following a few rules for safe supplementation you won’t go wrong. 1. Eat a well balanced diet. If your diet’s bad, a supplement won’t save you. For most people that means eating more fruits, vegetables and whole grains. Go to www.MyPyramid.gov for more information.2. Look at the nutritional quality of your diet and supplement where there are shortfalls. A good example of this is vitamin D. Research is showing that vitamin D is very important for preventing osteoporosis. It is difficult to get enough vitamin D from foods, and there is not enough light in the northern winter for skin to produce vitamin D. It has been suggested that vitamin D intake should be 800-1000 IU daily.  Add up what you get from your diet and make up the difference with supplements.3. Be aware of the maximum dosage and do not exceed it. Some supplements in high doses can actually harm you. In small doses zinc can enhance the immune system, but in excess it can actually hurt immune function. Keep this in mind when you are taking zinc for your cold while still taking a multivitamin and mineral supplement. The safe upper limit for zinc is 40 mg.4. Always inform your doctor about the dietary supplements you are taking. Some supplements may interact with medications. Antibiotics are poorly absorbed when taken at the same time as calcium and other minerals. The blood pressure medicine propranolol also becomes less effective when taken with some minerals.Local nutritionists were asked about the supplements they use. Their unanimous choice was the natural nutrients found in food, but it was clear that certain supplements have value. Maggie McHugh, MS, RD, CDN (founding partner of Eating for You and Baby Too, Inc.) takes a store brand prenatal vitamin daily (she’s expecting her third child) and an omega-3 fatty acid supplement (DHA) three times a week. Dorothy Humm, MBA, RD, CDE, CDN (owner of the Preferred Nutritionist Organization) takes Centrum Multivitamin daily, 400 IU vitamin E every other day, 500 mg vitamin C for cold symptoms, calcium if she doesn’t get enough from her diet, and acidophilus.Cyndi Weis, RD, CDN (owner of Breathe yoga studio and juice bar) uses whole food supplements such as ground flax seed, acai pulp (a very high antioxidant containing fruit), and Chinese herbs.Amy Blodgett, MPA, RD, CLC (Monroe County Women, Infants and Children Supplemental Nutrition Program) takes a prenatal vitamin and mother’s milk tea to aid milk production (she’s nursing her first baby).Molly Ranney, MS, RD, CDE, CDN (Breathe) takes a multivitamin and mineral formulation daily and occasionally adds whole food supplements such as flax seed and wheat grass juice.Ellen Pfeiffer, MS, MPH, RD (owner of Anju) takes a daily multivitamin, calcium with vitamin D and magnesium, fish oil, and 1-2 grams of vitamin C for allergies.Joanna Hill-Kennedy, RD, CPT, CPC (owner of Desired Dimensions, Inc.) takes a women’s multivitamin formulation daily plus calcium with vitamin D and magnesium. If you are uncertain about the supplements you are taking, it is worth seeking professional advice.Resources:

  • On Nutrition
  • Eating for You and Baby Too, Inc.
  • Preferred Nutritionist Organization
  • Breathe
  • Women, Infants and Children Supplemental Nutrition Program
  • Anju
  • Desired Dimensions, Inc.

 



[ Back to Home Page ]


Newsletter   |   About Us   |   Our Clients    |    Contact Us   |   Media   |   Links